Inspiration
    Now is the time and the day of your salvation - Alma 34:31
    Trending Posts
    • Characteristics vs. Attributes: Demystifying Lectures 3 and 4
    • Symbols, Images, Types, Metaphors, Similes, Parables, Motifs, Archetypes and more!
    • Do Latter-day Saints Need a Symbol?
    Trending
    • 26 – What is the doctrine of Christ and the fulness of the gospel?
    • #25 – How Nephi leverages scriptures heroes to his advantage
    • “Whoso knocketh, to him he will open”
    • Lehi’s escape from a polygamist Jerusalem
    • #24 – The attributes of a Heavenly Mother?
    • #23 – Comfort is the thief of growth
    • #22 – Coyote, chickens, and an impenetrable fortress designed in wisdom and love
    • New Photo of Joseph Smith Discovered? (for real this time?)
    oneClimbs.comoneClimbs.com
    • Podcast
      • Apple Podcasts
      • Spotify
      • Anchor.fm
    • Topics
      • Atonement
      • Symbolism
      • Temple Prep
      • Temples
      • Notebook
      • Vlog
    • Study Tools
      • Etymology Dictionary
      • Lectures on Faith.com
      • LDSSymbols.com
      • LDS Architecture Blog
      • Number in Scripture
      • Interpreter Foundation
      • Isaiah Explorer
      • ScriptureNotes
      • Septuagint (English)
      • Strong’s Condordance
      • The Book of Isaiah (IIT)
      • Webster’s 1828 Dictionary
    • About
      • About oneClimbs
      • Contact
    oneClimbs.comoneClimbs.com
    Home»Articles»Fluidity of Scripture
    Articles November 16, 20152 Mins Read

    Fluidity of Scripture

    There’s something interesting in 3 Nephi where Jesus starts quoting Isaiah (for three verses) and then stops because the people aren’t getting it. He then heals them, institutes the sacrament, calls apostles and then says that he’s returning to Isaiah but quotes several verses from Micah first. After all of this he picks up again where he left off on those three verses but he quotes them differently.

    I’ll break this down, let’s start in chapter 16 of 3 Nephi.

    3 Nephi 16:18-20

    Thy watchmen shall lift up the voice; with the voice together shall they sing, for they shall see eye to eye when the Lord shall bring again Zion. Break forth into joy, sing together, ye waste places of Jerusalem; for the Lord hath comforted his people, he hath redeemed Jerusalem. The Lord hath made bare his holy arm in the eyes of all the nations; and all the ends of the earth shall see the salvation of God.

    Then the following events occur:​

    • 3 Nephi 17: Healing, ministering of angels
    • 3 Nephi 18: sacrament, authority
    • 3 Nephi 19: baptism, gift of the Holy Ghost
    • 3 Nephi 20: sacrament again

    3 Nephi 20:32-35

    Then shall their watchmen lift up their voice, and with the voice together shall they sing; for they shall see eye to eye. Then will the Father gather them together again, and give unto them Jerusalem for the land of their inheritance. Then shall they break forth into joy—Sing together, ye waste places of Jerusalem; for the Father hath comforted his people, he hath redeemed Jerusalem. The Father hath made bare his holy arm in the eyes of all the nations; and all the ends of the earth shall see the salvation of the Father; and the Father and I are one.

    Interesting how Jesus quotes the scriptures differently to the people after certain things happen and certain teachings occur. This potentially illustrates how fluid scripture is in the hands of the Lord; it is adapted to the situation at hand. The fact that we observe this happening with Jesus causes one to consider some implications.

    Like Jesus, Nephi seems to modify or paraphrase scripture and so does Joseph Smith (such as in his “inspired translation” of the Bible). What was really happening there? It seems that scripture can be more malleable in the hands of one connected to the source. Is this distortion, clarification, likening or something else?

    Book of Mormon Scripture
    Previous ArticleFrom a Garden to a City
    Next Article Lynn G. Robbins’ Awesome Simplicity Talk
    Steve Reed

      I created oneClimbs as a place to organize my thoughts and share my observations with anyone who might find the information useful. Though I may speak passionately or convincingly in some of this content, PLEASE don't simply take my word alone on anything. Always seek the truth of all things through study and prayer in the name of Jesus Christ.

      2 Comments

      1. Richard J. Nobbe III on November 17, 2015 6:18 pm

        I think of Section 76 and the quote by Joseph Smith that often goes with it: “I could explain a hundredfold more than I ever have of the glories of the kingdoms manifested to me in the vision, were I permitted, and were the people prepared to receive them.” Perhaps some of the Saints did receive more as they prepared themselves for it, particularly those who were closest to the Prophet during the months that preceded his martyrdom, and were present with the prophet when he handed over the keys of the kingdom to the Twelve.

        Then you have Isaiah in the Old Testament and Isaiah in the Book of Mormon. There are important differences, and I think sometimes it goes beyond the actual translation. Who is speaking the words of Isaiah? To whom is he speaking? When is he speaking?

        You have the multiple stories of creation. You have the multiple Gospels of Jesus Christ. I’m reminded of a quote from the movie “Rudy” as a Catholic Priest is teaching a class on theology, “For us, divine inspiration does not mean that God possesses a man and simply dictates the inspired text to him. Rather, God implants into a man’s mind the general concept, and when He does that, He allows the man to write that in his historical context. So a man may have historical inaccuracies, but God allows those misunderstandings because what is important and inherent is the theological concept that God is getting across to mankind.”

        You ask, “Is this distortion, clarification, likening or something else?” I answer, “yes.” It is important to remember that in the end, our written scriptures are what Neal A. Maxwell used to call, “Mankind’s spiritual memory.”

        Reply
      2. IXQUS on December 5, 2015 12:53 am

        There is a bit of context missing, I think. 16:10 is not unlike Isaiah 28:9-13.

        Whom shall he teach knowledge? and whom shall he make to understand doctrine? them that are weaned from the milk, and drawn from the breasts. For precept must be upon precept, precept upon precept; line upon line, line upon line; here a little, and there a little:

        For with stammering lips and another tongue will he speak to this people. To whom he said, This is the rest wherewith ye may cause the weary to rest; and this is the refreshing:

        yet they would not hear.

        But the word of the Lord was unto them precept upon precept, precept upon precept; line upon line, line upon line; here a little, and there a little; that they might go, and fall backward, and be broken, and snared, and taken.

        There’s more going on here than a simple and static monologue, that is certain. The Word, in all of its beauty, is also a curse to those that would use the Father as a lever. If it can’t be plainly spoken and understood, if things of this world are so mysterious, it isn’t much of a leap to say that there’s not much use asking for any higher education. Rules aren’t always dictated by sadists, but quite the opposite rather.

        More so than anything, if we love someone, we do anything reasonable within in our power to hold onto them. If it fit your fancy and you could live it up on a beach all the time, sipping a Mai Tai, with no ill-effect, with everyone you love eventually doing exactly what they want to do, at your pleasure–making the effort to have what that requires available to them is worth anything in your power.

        When dividing an inheritance, sometimes a trust must be established. It isn’t simply the motives of the recipient that is put into question. It’s also that of the benefactor’s. At first, such proceedings might seem rather dry, but its purpose is basic survival, and then the more enjoyable meritocratic incentive. The process of building our trust in God, cleansing, committing, affirming, repeating is greatly symbolic, yet how they were taught is greatly semantic.

        Knowing what to say and when, in consideration of the Spirit, is sometimes simply avoiding monotony. A vainly repetitious prayer, for example, is something that is once held in high esteem only to be diminished by nearly immediately becoming screened through a colored lens. Teaching semantically requires a great deal of forethought, as topics aren’t easily learned through force. I guess most plainly said, the Word is the same as it was, but the perspective of others is the same as a plant: it can’t be forced to grow by flooding it with miracle gro. The Word is fluid by its encirclement of opposition, yet it’s unwavering, even when thought to be up against a wall.

        Reply

      Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

      Inspiration

      It is through the Human that we must climb up to the Divine. - George MacDonald

      New Post Email Notifications

      You can subscribe any time, and I will ONLY use your email to send you new post updates.

      Trending Posts
      • Articles
        Characteristics vs. Attributes: Demystifying Lectures 3 and 4

        Every now and then you find an answer that is extremely satisfying almost i...

      • Articles , Symbolism , Temples
        Symbols, Images, Types, Metaphors, Similes, Parables, Motifs, Archetypes and more!

        Perhaps most of us throw around the word "symbolism" without understanding...

      • Symbolism
        Do Latter-day Saints Need a Symbol?

        I came across an interesting paragraph on the blog "Dave's Mormon Inquiry"...

      • Articles
        Breakdown of Alma 32:28

        This is one of my favorite all-time verses for a multitude of reasons but I...

      • Articles
        There is no iron rod to the great and spacious building

        In the vision of the tree of life that Lehi and Nephi witnessed, a "great a...

      Recent Comments
      • Steve Reed on 26 – What is the doctrine of Christ and the fulness of the gospel?: “Hi Joel, thanks for your feedback and great questions. I think remarkable examples can come in many forms and people…”
      • Joel on 26 – What is the doctrine of Christ and the fulness of the gospel?: “Hey man, Thanks for doing this episode. I especially valued your sharing your experience with the baptism of fire. I’m…”
      • Steve Reed on A Proposed Reinterpretation of Jacob 2:30: “Thanks for your thoughts, Jeffery, it seems as though many people are starting to take a closer look at Jacob…”
      • Jeff on A Proposed Reinterpretation of Jacob 2:30: “Thank you for this! I had actually just finished writing out my thoughts on Jacob 2:30, which were almost identical…”
      • Jonathan on A Guide to Keeping Your Own “Small Plates”: “This is AWESOME! I’m going to be using some of these principles and sharing them with my seminary class tomorrow…”
      Blogroll
      • Academy for Temple Studies
      • Bruce Charlton's Notions
      • Conner's Connundrums
      • Gently Hew Stone
      • Hemlock Knots
      • Interpreter Foundation
      • Isaiah Explained
      • Isaiah Explorer
      • Junior Ganymede
      • Latter-day Saint Architecture Blog
      • Latter-day Saint Temples
      • LDSSymbols.com
      • Leading Saints
      • Number in Scripture by E. W. Bullinger
      • Sixty Symbols
      • Spiritual Arson Podcast
      • Strongs Concordance
      • TempleStudy
      • The Ancient Context of Joseph Smith's Egyptian Alphabet and Grammar
      • Webster's 1828 Dictionary
      New Post Email Notifications

      You can subscribe any time, and I will ONLY use your email to send you new post updates.

      Inspiration
      The beauty of symbols is that God can use them to teach us what we have the capacity to receive. One will see a shape, another will see a sign, and yet another will understand the elements of eternity.
      About this Site

      I created oneClimbs as a place to organize my thoughts and share my observations with anyone who might find the information useful. All content on this site is considered a work in progress that is often updated when new insights are obtained.

      oneClimbs.com

      LecturesOnFaith.com  //  LDSSymbols.com

      © 2023 oneClimbs. All content unique to oneClimbs is fair use. All other content is property of the respective copyright owner. oneClimbs.com is not owned, controlled, or affiliated with The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. All views and opinions are of the authors here who are solely responsible for their content and should not be interpreted as official statements of Church doctrine, belief, or practice, unless specifically stated and correctly referenced.

      Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.