Inspiration
    Remembering brings the power of the past to the present
    Trending Posts
    • Characteristics vs. Attributes: Demystifying Lectures 3 and 4
    • God’s Plan is Only Messy From Our Perspective
    • Do Latter-day Saints Need a Symbol?
    Trending
    • 26 – What is the doctrine of Christ and the fulness of the gospel?
    • #25 – How Nephi leverages scriptures heroes to his advantage
    • “Whoso knocketh, to him he will open”
    • Lehi’s escape from a polygamist Jerusalem
    • #24 – The attributes of a Heavenly Mother?
    • #23 – Comfort is the thief of growth
    • #22 – Coyote, chickens, and an impenetrable fortress designed in wisdom and love
    • New Photo of Joseph Smith Discovered? (for real this time?)
    oneClimbs.comoneClimbs.com
    • Podcast
      • Apple Podcasts
      • Spotify
      • Anchor.fm
    • Topics
      • Atonement
      • Symbolism
      • Temple Prep
      • Temples
      • Notebook
      • Vlog
    • Study Tools
      • Etymology Dictionary
      • Lectures on Faith.com
      • LDSSymbols.com
      • LDS Architecture Blog
      • Number in Scripture
      • Interpreter Foundation
      • Isaiah Explorer
      • ScriptureNotes
      • Septuagint (English)
      • Strong’s Condordance
      • The Book of Isaiah (IIT)
      • Webster’s 1828 Dictionary
    • About
      • About oneClimbs
      • Contact
    oneClimbs.comoneClimbs.com
    Home»Articles»Is Agency a Negative Concept?
    Articles September 15, 20163 Mins Read

    Is Agency a Negative Concept?

    A few days ago I heard someone at church talk about agency as a “gift” but that got me thinking if it really was or not. Perhaps you are thinking, “Well, of course it’s a gift, doesn’t everything good come from God?” That’s one way of looking at it but let me share a quote from Frédéric Bastiat that slipped into my mind at that moment that got me thinking about it differently.

    As a friend of mine once remarked, this negative concept of law is so true that the statement, the purpose of the law is to cause justice to reign, is not a rigorously accurate statement. It ought to be stated that the purpose of the law is to prevent injustice from reigning. In fact, it is injustice, instead of justice, that has an existence of its own. Justice is achieved only when injustice is absent. (Bastiat, The Law)

    I’m going to change that up a little and substitute God for the word law, agency for justice and captivity for injustice and we’ll see how it reads.

    …this negative concept of [agency] is so true that the statement, the purpose of [God] is to cause [agency] to reign, is not a rigorously accurate statement. It ought to be stated that the purpose of [God] is to prevent [captivity] from reigning. In fact, it is [captivity] instead of [agency], that has an existence of its own. [Agency] is achieved only when [captivity] is absent.

    It’s an interesting way of looking at it but it appears to ring true in my mind. Let’s explore it as if it is… We didn’t fight for agency before this world, we fought to eliminate captivity and this is why Satan and his followers had to be made absent or cast out. Whatever Satan’s motivations or intentions were, the ends would cause captivity to reign and God could not allow that or it could have had the same effect as allowing mercy to rob justice:

    What, do ye suppose that mercy can rob justice? I say unto you, Nay; not one whit. If so, God would cease to be God. (Alma 42:25)

    God cannot allow mercy to rob justice and it may be safe to say that he cannot allow captivity to rob agency as well or he would cease to be God. How can we prevent captivity from reigning in our fellow brothers and sisters?

    Many are in physical captivity due to crimes, debt, or health, while others are in a psychological captivity like depression, sorrow, addiction, etc. and then there is spiritual captivity due to sin, apathy, anger, unforgiving, doubt, or fear. I believe that our current placement in the world is sufficient enough to do great things among the people around us as we utilize friendships, callings, social networks, and awareness to act in a manner that helps to liberate captive souls from their respective prisons.

    In this effort, the gift is not agency (at least not directly), the gift is liberation from captivity which then creates a state where agency can be achieved.

    Agency Frédéric Bastiat Justice The Law
    Previous ArticleLessons Learned From (Almost) Five Years on a Plant-based Diet
    Next Article Characteristics vs. Attributes: Demystifying Lectures 3 and 4
    Steve Reed

      I created oneClimbs as a place to organize my thoughts and share my observations with anyone who might find the information useful. Though I may speak passionately or convincingly in some of this content, PLEASE don't simply take my word alone on anything. Always seek the truth of all things through study and prayer in the name of Jesus Christ.

      Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

      Inspiration

      The discomfort one feels from the scornful mocking coming from the great and spacious building is directly proportional to the value one ascribes to their opinions.

      New Post Email Notifications

      You can subscribe any time, and I will ONLY use your email to send you new post updates.

      Trending Posts
      • Articles
        Characteristics vs. Attributes: Demystifying Lectures 3 and 4

        Every now and then you find an answer that is extremely satisfying almost i...

      • Articles , Quotes
        God’s Plan is Only Messy From Our Perspective

        I don't know who wrote the following story but I remembered hearing it a lo...

      • Symbolism
        Do Latter-day Saints Need a Symbol?

        I came across an interesting paragraph on the blog "Dave's Mormon Inquiry"...

      • Articles , Symbolism , Temples
        Symbols, Images, Types, Metaphors, Similes, Parables, Motifs, Archetypes and more!

        Perhaps most of us throw around the word "symbolism" without understanding...

      • Atonement
        Repentance: a process of addition not subtraction

        I came across this post the other day that had some interesting perspective...

      Recent Comments
      • Steve Reed on 26 – What is the doctrine of Christ and the fulness of the gospel?: “Hi Joel, thanks for your feedback and great questions. I think remarkable examples can come in many forms and people…”
      • Joel on 26 – What is the doctrine of Christ and the fulness of the gospel?: “Hey man, Thanks for doing this episode. I especially valued your sharing your experience with the baptism of fire. I’m…”
      • Steve Reed on A Proposed Reinterpretation of Jacob 2:30: “Thanks for your thoughts, Jeffery, it seems as though many people are starting to take a closer look at Jacob…”
      • Jeff on A Proposed Reinterpretation of Jacob 2:30: “Thank you for this! I had actually just finished writing out my thoughts on Jacob 2:30, which were almost identical…”
      • Jonathan on A Guide to Keeping Your Own “Small Plates”: “This is AWESOME! I’m going to be using some of these principles and sharing them with my seminary class tomorrow…”
      Blogroll
      • Academy for Temple Studies
      • Bruce Charlton's Notions
      • Conner's Connundrums
      • Gently Hew Stone
      • Hemlock Knots
      • Interpreter Foundation
      • Isaiah Explained
      • Isaiah Explorer
      • Junior Ganymede
      • Latter-day Saint Architecture Blog
      • Latter-day Saint Temples
      • LDSSymbols.com
      • Leading Saints
      • Number in Scripture by E. W. Bullinger
      • Sixty Symbols
      • Spiritual Arson Podcast
      • Strongs Concordance
      • TempleStudy
      • The Ancient Context of Joseph Smith's Egyptian Alphabet and Grammar
      • Webster's 1828 Dictionary
      New Post Email Notifications

      You can subscribe any time, and I will ONLY use your email to send you new post updates.

      Inspiration
      For every expert there is an equal and opposite expert. - Arthur C. Clarke
      About this Site

      I created oneClimbs as a place to organize my thoughts and share my observations with anyone who might find the information useful. All content on this site is considered a work in progress that is often updated when new insights are obtained.

      oneClimbs.com

      LecturesOnFaith.com  //  LDSSymbols.com

      © 2023 oneClimbs. All content unique to oneClimbs is fair use. All other content is property of the respective copyright owner. oneClimbs.com is not owned, controlled, or affiliated with The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. All views and opinions are of the authors here who are solely responsible for their content and should not be interpreted as official statements of Church doctrine, belief, or practice, unless specifically stated and correctly referenced.

      Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.